Free shipping for orders $75+ to the lower 48 states

Retailer Picks

Best Loved. Most Requested.
These are the teas our customers can’t stop talking about—favorites chosen by our retailers for their popularity and staying power. Whether you’re steeping a colonial classic or savoring a seasonal blend, you’ll find the tried-and-true teas that keep people coming back for more.

21 Results

21 Results

Clear all
picture of the exterior envelope for 1 gallon peach iced tea packet; says a refreshing black tea blend
Tea bag on a white background

Peach Iced Tea - 1 Gallon Envelope

4.7 (7)

$8.00

$8.00

In stock

A matte black tea tin labeled 'Elderberry' by Oliver Pluff & Co. containing 20 pyramid style teabags.
Tea canister labeled 'Elderberry' with a glass of tea, ginger root, and green leaves on a wooden table.

Elderberry Teabags Tea Tin

4.7 (29)

$16.95

$16.95

In stock

red tea pouch with Orange Peel, Ginger, Cinnamon, Allspice, Cloves sprinkled in front and white teabag on counter
two iced glasses of tea with lemon slices sitting on bronze platter

Wine Spices Wassail - 1 Gallon Package

5.0 (3)

$9.50

$9.50

In stock

small silver tea tin with blue background
brewing instructions on small silver tea tin with blue background

Wine Spices Wassail Kit

5.0 (5)

$20.00

$20.00

In stock

black tea tin with orange pattern against blue backdrop
Brewing instructions on black tea tin with orange pattern against blue backdrop

No. 5 Ginger

4.8 (16)

$16.95

$16.95

In stock

black tea tin with graphic of leaves on front
brewing instructions on black tea tin with graphic of leaves on front

Passionfruit Peach Loose Tea Tin

4.8 (11)

$16.95

$16.95

In stock

black tea tin with graphic of leaves on front
Tea canisters with fruit and berries on a wooden surface, featuring Oliver Pluff & Co branding.

Passionfruit Peach Teabags Tea Tin

4.8 (20)

$16.95

$16.95

In stock

orange tea pouch with halloween crows on label. Loose lead tea and cinnamon sticks sprinkled in front with white tea bag
orange pillow box that reads 'wassail cider spices' on wooden tabletop with woven pumpkins in the foreground and background

Cider Spices Wassail - 1 Gallon Package

4.4 (5)

$9.50

$9.50

In stock

silver tea tin with orange flower graphic against blue backdrop
silver tray holding 4 clear glasses filled with tea, apple slices and cinnamon sticks. on a table outside

Cider Spices Wassail Kit

5.0 (4)

$20.00

$20.00

In stock

A package of Witches Brew Cider Spices Wassail with cinnamon sticks, ground ginger, and nutmeg displayed in front of a cauldron-shaped graphic on the package.
brewed cup of cider wassail in front of package of witches brew with lit candle
New

Witches Brew Cider Spices Wassail - 1 Gallon Package

4.7 (7)

$9.50

$9.50

In stock

black tea tin against blue backdrop
brewing instructions on backside of black tea tin

Masala Chai Loose Tea Tin

4.7 (14)

$16.95

$16.95

In stock

black tea tin against blue backdrop
Cup of masala chai with a tin of masala chai mix on a wooden table.

Masala Chai Teabags Tea Tin

4.8 (15)

$16.95

$16.95

In stock

Blackberry Teabags Tea Tin
Tea canisters with fruit and tea leaves on a wooden surface, featuring Oliver Pluff & Co branding.

Blackberry Teabags Tea Tin

4.8 (36)

$16.95

$16.95

In stock

black tea tin with photo from early america people and blue backdrop
Blackberry product on a marble surface with a bowl of blackberries and greenery.

Blackberry Loose Tea Tin

5.0 (13)

$16.95

$16.95

In stock

orange firm tea pouch with cinnamon sticks and loose leaf tea sprinkled in front
orange clove pillow box on bar with lemons

Orange Clove Hot Toddy - 1 Gallon Package

4.3 (18)

$9.50

$9.50

In stock

small silver tea tin with yellow flower graphic
Two glasses of hot toddy with a spoonful of spices on a wooden table.

Orange Clove Hot Toddy Kit

4.3 (7)

$20.00

$20.00

In stock

Tea canister labeled 'Elderberry' by Oliver Pluff & Co on a blue background
Dry tea leaves with dried elderberries on a transparent background

Elderberry Loose Tea Tin

$16.95

$16.95

In stock

A cylindrical white tin of Oliver Pluff & Co. Decaffeinated Ceylon Black Tea with a black lid, set against a dark blue textured background.
A circular pile of dark brown loose-leaf tea leaves on a solid green background.

Decaf Ceylon Black Tea Loose Tea Tin

5.0 (13)

$16.95

$16.95

In stock

A cylindrical tin of Oliver Pluff & Co. Decaffeinated Ceylon Black Tea, featuring a white label and black lid, set against a solid dark blue background.
A cylindrical metal tin of Olive Puff & Co. Decaffeinated Ceylon Tea, featuring a white label with black text and illustrations, a black lid, and a dark brown tea fill visible at the top, set against a textured blue background.

Decaf Ceylon Black Tea Teabags Tin

5.0 (1)

$16.95

$16.95

In stock

cylinder tea tin with black lid that reads decaffeinated sencha green tea on white label
A cylindrical canister of decaffeinated sencha green tea, featuring a cream-colored label with green text and illustrations, a black lid, and a dark red inner rim, set against a textured dark blue background.

Decaf Sencha Green Tea Teabags Tin

5.0 (13)

$16.95

$16.95

In stock

A cylindrical canister of Oliver Pluff & Co. Decaffeinated Sencha Green Tea, featuring an off-white label with green botanical illustrations and a black lid, set against a solid dark blue background.
A circular pile of loose-leaf tea leaves, showing a mix of dark brown and olive-green dried foliage, isolated on a solid green background.

Decaf Sencha Green Tea Loose Tea Tin

5.0 (13)

$16.95

$16.95

In stock

Veteran Owned
American Made
Award Winning